How Evidence of Adultery or Other “Faults” Can Win You a Bigger Settlement in Connecticut
A common misconception I hear from clients in marital cases is related to the no fault divorce. In a nutshell, many clients mistakenly believe that if they file for no fault divorce, the reasons they filed for divorce will have no bearing on the settlement. This misunderstanding can significantly impact their divorce proceedings and potentially cause them to receive a smaller settlement.
Many Bluevision clients live in Connecticut, where spouses seeking divorce have the option of filing for divorce under fault grounds or no fault. Under the no fault provision, the spouse seeking a divorce might cite as the grounds for divorce “irreconcilable differences”, “incompatibility”, or simply that the marriage itself is “irretrievably broken”. Alternatively, the spouse could file for divorce under one of the following fault grounds:
- Adultery
- A separation for 18 months or more
- Fraudulent contract
- Willful desertion for one year
- Seven years absence when the spouse has not been heard from
- Habitual intemperance (i.e., active alcoholism)
- Intolerable cruelty
- Sentence to life imprisonment
- Conviction of a crime involving conjugal duty which is punishable with imprisonment for at least a year (these are sex crimes)
- Legal confinement in a hospital or institution for mental illness for an accumulated period of 5 years within the last six years
The court may take those grounds into consideration when deciding issues of custody, alimony, child support, and division of property. But here is the key point that many clients misunderstand: The court can take any of the marital circumstances into consideration even in the case of no fault divorces. That means that even if a spouse files citing that the marriage suffered an “irretrievable breakdown”, the spouse can still present evidence of the circumstances that led to the breakdown, and the court can consider that evidence when determining the outcome of the divorce.
There are two legal theories that dictate how marital property is divided: equitable distribution and community property. Most states, including Connecticut, use equitable distribution, but nine states have community property laws: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin. In community property states, all property acquired by the couple during the marriage is divided equally. However, in equitable distribution states, the court may consider outside factors when dividing the assets and property. In Connecticut, the court can consider the following:
- The length of the marriage
- The age and physical and emotional health of the spouses
- The income or property brought to the marriage by each spouse
- The standard of living established during the marriage
- Any written agreement made by the spouses before or during the marriage concerning property distribution
- The economic situation of each spouse at the time the division of property becomes effective
- The income and earning potential of each spouse
- The contribution by each spouse to the education, training or earning power of the other spouse
- The contribution of each spouse as to the acquisition of any marital property as well as the contribution of a spouse as a homemaker
- The tax consequences to each spouse
- The present value of any marital property
- The need for the custodial parent to remain in the marital home and keep possession of household effects
- The marital debts and liabilities and the ability of each spouse to pay those debts
- Any other factors the court may feel are relevant
Frequently, clients mistakenly believe that if they are not seeking divorce under fault grounds, then there is no reason for them to spend the time or money gathering evidence of the marital circumstances which led to divorce (such as adultery or alcohol abuse) . But, for clients living in equitable distribution states, the reality is that the court can take into consideration any evidence or testimony that is relevant to the marital conditions, even for no fault divorces. Check on the specific laws in your state to understand what factors a court can consider, as they may differ by state. While we are not lawyers at Bluevision, we think it’s important to understand the legal implications of the cases we manage. We also make sure that our clients consider the key aspects of their case, so that our investigative services can help them achieve the best possible outcome.
Hi, cool post. I have been wondering about this topic,so thanks for writing.
Great post! I’ll subscribe right now wth my feedreader software!